Does Higher Ad Strength Improve Performance?
TL;DR: Adalysis's October 27, 2026 study of 5,900+ accounts compared two responsive search ads with different Ad Strength in the same ad group. The higher-rated ad got more impressions in 63% of ad groups, but had the better conversion rate in only 45% and a CPA 11.8% higher overall. Adalysis says pinning is the main reason, since weaker-rated ads pin more. If you don't pin, aim for Excellent. If you do, Ad Strength stops being a reliable guide, so judge by CPA and conversions.
Ad Strength is the rating Google shows on every responsive search ad, from Poor to Excellent. A lot of advertisers chase Excellent because it looks like a score you can win. Adalysis reran its 2022 study on this question in 2026, and the answer is more mixed than the rating suggests. I read the study itself and Google's own Ad Strength help page, and I've split what they say from what I'd infer.
What Adalysis tested
The study was published October 27, 2026, and uses data from more than 5,900 Adalysis accounts. The part about two ads uses these criteria:
- Same ad group, two ads. Ad groups with exactly two active RSAs that had different Ad Strength ratings, with the same targeting.
- Non-branded only. Branded ads were excluded.
- Enough data. Each ad was active at least 30 days with at least 250 impressions, and each ad group had at least one conversion.
- No final URL expansion. Campaigns using it were excluded, since it can ignore pinning.
- Unweighted. Every ad group counts the same, so ad groups with millions of impressions don't swamp small ones.
One thing to know: Adalysis says this is a different dataset from its RSA pinning study, even though both cover 5,900+ accounts. This one requires a conversion in the ad group, while the pinning study requires one on each ad.
What happened when two ads competed
| Question | Result |
|---|---|
| Which ad got more impressions? | Higher Ad Strength won in 63% of ad groups, with 63% more impressions overall |
| Which ad had the better CTR? | Higher Ad Strength won in 52.5% of ad groups |
| Which ad had the better conversion rate? | Higher Ad Strength won in 45% (lower-rated won in 55%) |
| Which ad had the better conversions per impression? | Lower-rated ad won in 54.3% of ad groups |
| Which ad had the lower CPA? | Lower-rated ad won in 51.5% of ad groups |
| Overall CPA | Higher Ad Strength ads had an 11.8% higher CPA across all ad groups |
A few details that matter:
- The gap changes the odds. Excellent against Poor got more impressions 78% of the time. Two ratings apart was 66%, and Good against Average was 59%.
- CPA looks like a coin flip until you read the size. Each side won about half the ad groups, but Adalysis says when the lower-rated ad won, it won by a lot. That is where the 11.8% comes from.
- CTR is close. Adalysis says that within a shared ad group, Ad Strength makes little difference to CTR, and that aggregate CTR was actually higher for lower-rated ads.
- Comparison with 2022. The higher-rated ad got more impressions 56.8% of the time then, against 63% now, and won on conversion rate 45.8% then, against 45.1% now.
Why the lower-rated ad often wins
Adalysis's explanation is pinning. Pinning cuts the number of unique lines Google can count, so pinned ads tend to score lower. In ad groups with two ads at different strengths, usually one is pinned and the other isn't, and Adalysis says pinned ads usually convert better.
I'd treat that as Adalysis's reading, not a proven cause. Adalysis adds its own caveat in the same study: advertisers who pin all three headlines are more likely to be active ad testers, so their strong results may reflect rigorous testing rather than low Ad Strength. And in its separate pinning study, Adalysis reports only small differences in conversion rate between unpinned and two-position pinned ads, with fully pinned ads described as vastly superior but no exact figure given in the text.
Also, the pattern is not "ignore Ad Strength." For unpinned ads, Adalysis found that CTR and conversions per impression rose at each step up in rating, and conversion rates generally did too, with a small exception from Poor to Average. Excellent made up 33% of unpinned ads.
Does Google use Ad Strength to pick the ad?
Here the sources disagree, so I'll lay it out:
- Adalysis concludes that Google has increased its reliance on Ad Strength when deciding which ad to show, based on the rise from 56.8% to 63% over four years.
- Google's help page says Ad Strength "isn't used to calculate Ad Rank, Quality Score, or auction wins," and that it doesn't directly influence serving eligibility. Google describes it as feedback for creating and editing ads.
- My reading: both can be true at once. Adalysis can see that higher-rated ads get more impressions. It cannot see why. The rating may track signals Google does use, without being one itself. That's an inference, and I can't confirm it from either source.
Independent data also warns against treating Excellent as a performance guarantee. An April 2026 Optmyzr study of about 20,000 accounts found Excellent ads had the worst CPA in its dataset ($28.68) and lowest conversion rate (4.97%), with Average best. Optmyzr says its data is observational and skews toward experienced advertisers, so I'd read it as a second data point, not a rebuttal.
Google's own page makes a different claim: moving RSAs and sitelinks from Poor to Excellent is associated with 15% more conversions on average, based on Google internal data from August 2025. That's an association from Google's data, and it covers sitelinks as well as the ad.
How to reach Excellent
Per Adalysis's data:
- Unpinned ads: use at least 11 different headlines. Mix keyword headlines, benefits, features, calls to action, and authority statements.
- A count isn't enough. Only 44% of ads with 15 or more headlines reached Excellent, and some ads with dozens of assets were still Poor. Variety matters more than volume.
- Pinning one position: Excellent is still possible but rare.
- Pinning two or more positions: Adalysis says you can't reach Excellent.
- Which headline you pin matters. Google weights headline 1 most, then headline 2, then headline 3. Pinning headline 2 lowers Ad Strength less than pinning headline 1.
- Pinning several assets to one headline helps. Three or more assets on a single headline can still reach Excellent.
For pinned ads, Adalysis suggests removing the pins, editing until the ad is Excellent, re-pinning, and then improving assets until it's at least Average (Good if you pin only one headline). Google's own help page says to avoid pinning unless necessary, and to pin several unique versions to one position if you must pin for compliance.
What I'd do
My view is that Ad Strength is mainly a lever for impressions, not for conversions. Within an ad group, a Poor ad simply gets shown less.
In each important ad group, I'd keep one unpinned ad built up to Excellent, and next to it one pinned ad written to our rules. Then I'd decide by CPA and conversions, not by what Google rates best.
Two practical cautions:
- Expect a slow test. Adalysis says the bigger the rating gap, the longer a test takes, since the lower-rated ad gets fewer impressions. For a local business with a few conversions a month, that can mean waiting a while before the result means anything.
- Google's advice differs. Its help page recommends at least two ads rated Good or Excellent per ad group. A pinned ad written to strict rules may not reach that, which is why I'd judge it on results.
What's confirmed, what's reported, what's unknown
Stated in Adalysis's published study (I read it directly):
- The numbers in the table above, and the 2022 comparison.
- The asset and pinning findings in the section on reaching Excellent.
Reported by Adalysis, but its own interpretation:
- That pinning is the main reason lower-rated ads perform better.
- That Google has increased its reliance on Ad Strength.
Not confirmed by Google:
- That Ad Strength affects which ad gets shown. Google's help page says the opposite.
Unknown:
- How many ad groups are in the two-ad comparison, since the page doesn't say.
- Whether these results hold for your industry or for low-volume accounts. the accounts are Adalysis's own, so they may not look like the average advertiser.
Frequently asked questions
Does a higher Ad Strength improve Google Ads performance? For unpinned ads, mostly yes, according to Adalysis: CTR and conversions per impression rose with each step up in rating. When two ads sit in the same ad group, the higher-rated one got more impressions in 63% of ad groups but had the better conversion rate in only 45%.
Should I aim for Excellent Ad Strength? If you don't pin, Adalysis says yes. If you pin, it says Ad Strength stops being a good guide, and you should aim for at least Average or Good, then judge the ad on CPA and conversions.
How many headlines do I need for Excellent? Adalysis recommends at least 11 different headlines for an unpinned ad, with a mix of keyword, benefit, feature, call to action, and authority lines. More isn't automatically better: only 44% of ads with 15 or more headlines reached Excellent.
Does pinning lower Ad Strength? Yes. Pinning one headline can still reach Excellent but it's rare, and pinning two or more positions cannot, per Adalysis. Pinning headline 2 lowers it less than pinning headline 1.
Does Google use Ad Strength in the auction? Google's help page says it isn't used to calculate Ad Rank, Quality Score, or auction wins. Adalysis observes that higher-rated ads get more impressions and concludes Google relies on it more, but it can't show the mechanism.
If you're not sure whether your RSAs are being tested properly, or whether pinning is helping or hurting, that's part of what a PPC account audit checks. For ongoing ad testing and optimization, see Performance Max and Google Ads management.
Related posts
- Smart Bidding Learning Phase: 50 ConversionsGoogle's Smart Bidding guidance is shifting from weeks to a conversion count. Here's what that actually means for low-volume accounts.
- What Is a Google Ads Conversion?A conversion is a specific action you've told Google Ads to count as valuable, not a click or a visit. Here's what counts and how to set one up.
- Google Ads Now Bids to Your Actual TargetStarting August 17, 2026, Google Ads bids up to your actual CPA/ROAS target instead of undershooting it. Here's what that means for your budget.
Related services
- PPC Account AuditGoogle Ads account audit for US small businesses: a structured review of structure, wasted spend and tracking, with a prioritized fix list.
- Performance Marketing ManagementPerformance marketing management for US local and ecommerce businesses: Google and Microsoft Ads, tracking and reporting tied to leads and revenue.
Questions about how this affects your account?
Let's talk